Beat Phase A spot-check: raised defaults (3.22.0 candidate)
Date: 2026-09-13
Tip: feat/beat-phase-a (A.2 marketing + A.3/A.4 app/overlay craft)
Against: visual-compete PASS tip e79f828 / Phase 5 sign-off
2026-09-12-visual-bar-signoff-pass.md
Programme: umbrella docs/plans/brickwork-beat-tailwind-plus.md Phase A.5
Issue: icvoss/django-brickwork#541
Scope
Spot-check only: confirm zero-kwargs craft raises on white canvas do not regress the meet-bar axes that already PASS. This is not the Phase F win scorecard and does not authorise beat/prefer claim language.
Method
- Read source CSS for touched selectors against the card 3.21.0 ambient + fg-mix edge recipe.
- Confirm dark theme strips ambient back to plain elevation.
- Run focused pytest ambient assertions for marketing and app/overlays.
- Note residual tracker items that remain out of this spot-check.
Surfaces checked
| Surface family | Selectors | Spot finding |
|---|---|---|
| Marketing cards/bands | feature-grid cards, testimonial, pricing tier, stat-band, CTA tint | Edge + ambient present on light; dark resets present |
| Marketing type | hero heading/lede, pricing table heading, CTA heading | Wrap/family craft only; no layout fork |
| App chrome | filter bar, data-table wrap, empty-state (md), stats | Edge + ambient; sm empty-state stays unframed |
| Overlays | modal panel, slide-over, dropdown panel, toast | Edge + ambient under existing elevation ladder |
| Shells | topbar, marketing header, auth/centred panels, sidebar edge | Light lift / stronger edge; nav active tokens left alone |
Regression vs visual-compete PASS
| Axis (VISUAL-BAR) | Spot finding |
|---|---|
| Navigation | No substrate-owned regression noted; header elev additive |
| Typography | Additive wrap/family only |
| Forms | Untouched in this pass |
| Density | Existing density tokens retained |
| Spacing rhythm | Marketing section gaps unchanged |
| Elevation / edge | Strengthened deliberately (CHANGELOG consumer terms) |
| Colour / contrast | Token-only mixes; inverse/ghost AA from 3.21.0 retained |
| Overlay / focus | Elevation floors kept; axe fixtures not regenerated in this note |
Verdict: no meet-bar regression observed in this spot-check. Craft changes are intentional default raises for beat Phase A, not meet-bar repairs.
Residuals (not blockers for A.5)
- Named
marketing_footer_groupscomponent remains Phase B (#542); #500 example/shell honesty already closed. - Full still regeneration and independent win scorecard wait for Phase F (#545) after B/C/D.
- Homepage proof (A.6) follows package release pin on brickworkui.com.
Honesty
Do not cite this note as a win against Tailwind Plus. Cite it only as Phase A defaults spot-check clearance before release and homepage redo.